By Hope O’Rukevbe EGHAGHA
There are certain practices, political, financial, or cultural that have become synonymous with, in the case of the practice in question, endemic in the Nigerian state that we have gotten used to them to the detriment of the country. One of such practices is the much-talked about ‘fuel subsidy’. Right from the IBB days, the federal government had talked about abolishing fuel subsidy. Each time the government claimed to remove subsidy, the price of petrol and petroleum products also rose. The government often responded by introducing palliative measures to cushion the harsh effects on the citizenry. But the problem had continued.
For over four decades, Nigerians were told a simple story: the government was helping the poor by paying part of the cost of petrol, so that fuel would be cheap. This was called fuel subsidy. It was a lie. Fuel subsidy in Nigeria was never really a subsidy for the poor. But indeed, it was a scam — a well-organized system designed by a small circle in government, in the NNPC, and among oil marketers to steal public money, enrich themselves, and keep Nigerians poor while pretending to help them. The removal of subsidy in 2023 did not create the scam. It only exposed what had been happening for years.
To understand the scam, we must first understand what subsidy was supposed to be. Nigeria is one of the largest oil producers in the world. It exports crude oil and imports refined petrol because its four refineries in Port Harcourt, Warri, and Kaduna were deliberately allowed to die. The government claimed that because Nigerians were suffering, it would pay the difference between the real landing cost of petrol and the pump price. For example, if petrol cost N500 per litre to import, but the pump price was N185, government would pay N315 as subsidy.
On paper, that sounds like compassion. In practice, it became the biggest fraud in Nigerian history. The core of the scam was volume. Nobody ever knew how much petrol Nigeria actually consumed. The NNPC and marketers claimed Nigeria consumed 60 million, 70 million, even 90 million litres per day. But independent experts said the real consumption was around 30 to 40 million litres. Where did the extra 30 to 50 million litres go? It went nowhere. It existed only on paper.
Marketers would claim they imported 30,000 metric tonnes of petrol, collect subsidy for it, but discharge only half, or nothing at all. They forged import documents, bills of lading, and invoices. They claimed subsidy for fuel that was diverted to neighbouring countries like Cameroon, Benin, Togo, and Niger, where it was sold at full price. They claimed subsidy for the same cargo twice. They claimed subsidy for fuel that never left the depot.
The 2012 House of Representatives probe into the subsidy regime, led by Farouk Lawan, revealed the shocking scale. The committee found that the subsidy paid in 2011 alone was N2.5 trillion — far more than the N245 billion budgeted. It found that 72 marketers collected subsidy for fuel they never imported. It found companies that were registered only weeks before they started collecting billions. It found that the Petroleum Products Pricing Regulatory Agency (PPPRA) was issuing import allocations to companies with no tank farms, no trucks, no filling stations — briefcase companies.
That was not a mistake. That was a criminal enterprise. The NNPC was the biggest thief in the system. Under the subsidy regime, the NNPC was both the player and the referee. It imported fuel, it regulated imports, it claimed subsidy, and it audited itself. It kept two sets of books. It deducted subsidy directly from crude oil sales before remitting anything to the Federation Account. That meant state governments, local governments, and the Nigerian people never even saw the money. It simply disappeared.
Year after year, the Auditor-General’s reports showed that the NNPC could not account for trillions of naira. It could not explain how much crude it sold, how much petrol it imported, or how much subsidy it paid. When the National Assembly asked questions, the NNPC gave conflicting figures. When the public demanded an audit, the NNPC said its accounts were too complex. How can a country run like that? It can only run like that if the theft is deliberate and protected from the very top.
Successive presidents knew what was happening. They knew the refineries were not working because if the refineries worked, the import scam would die. They knew the subsidy figures were inflated, but they kept approving payments. Why? Because the subsidy cabal funded elections, funded political parties, and funded politicians. The scam was the ATM of Nigerian politics.
The most wicked part of the scam is that it was sold as help for the poor, while the poor got almost nothing from it. The real beneficiaries were the rich: the man with three SUVs and a big generator, the factory owner, the politician with a convoy, and the smuggler who took cheap Nigerian petrol across the border to sell at double the price. The poor paid for it through the theft of money that should have built schools, hospitals, roads, and power plants. Think about it: between 2006 and 2023, Nigeria spent over N20 trillion on fuel subsidy. That is more than the entire budget for education and health combined for many years. What did we get for it? No refineries. No stable electricity. No good roads. No functional hospitals. The money was stolen.
Meanwhile, Nigerians were told that if subsidy was removed, they would suffer. So they accepted the suffering of no light, no water, no jobs, just to keep cheap petrol. That is the genius of the scam: make the victims defend their own exploitation. To keep the scam alive, the refineries had to remain dead. And they did. Every few years, the government would announce billions of naira for Turn-Around Maintenance (TAM) for the refineries. Billions were spent. Nothing changed. Port Harcourt Refinery alone gulped over $1.5 billion in TAM between 1999 and 2023 without producing a litre consistently. Warri and Kaduna refineries were in the same condition.
*The Fourth Part of the Scam: The Turn-Around Maintenance Fraud*
To keep the scam alive, the refineries had to remain dead. And they did.
Every few years, the government would announce billions of naira for Turn-Around Maintenance (TAM) for the refineries. Billions were spent. Nothing changed. Port Harcourt Refinery alone gulped over $1.5 billion in TAM between 1999 and 2023 without producing a litre consistently. Warri and Kaduna refineries were in the same condition.
If a mechanic collects money to repair your car for 20 years and the car never moves, you would call him a thief. That is what happened with the refineries. The TAM money was part of the subsidy scam — a way to keep Nigeria importing fuel so the subsidy payments could continue.
When Dangote Refinery finally started producing in 2024, it exposed the lie that Nigeria could not refine its own fuel. A private businessman built in a few years what the government claimed was impossible for 40 years. Why? Because some powerful persons in government never wanted the refineries to work.
When on May 29, 2023, President Tinubu went ‘off script’ and said: “Subsidy is gone,” many Nigerians cried. Petrol price jumped from N185 to over N900 and now N1340. Transport costs exploded. Food prices exploded. Life became harder. This tough decision fundamental as it was, was not followed with the necessary tools that would reduce the stress occasioned by the policy shift. The optics have remained bad for the incumbent President. And the people hold him responsible for the suffering in the land!
But we must be honest: the hardship did not start with subsidy removal. The hardship started when the subsidy money was stolen for decades. The removal only stopped the bleeding. For the first time, the NNPC could no longer deduct trillions in secret. State governments began receiving more allocation. The money that was going to the cabal was now, at least on paper, going to the Federation Account.
The question now is: will the saved money be used to build Nigeria, or will it be stolen in another form? The same politicians who ran the subsidy scam are still in power. The same NNPC, now called NNPCL, is still opaque. The same system of budget padding, inflated contracts, and abandoned projects continues. That is why Nigerians must not forget. Fuel subsidy was not a policy failure. It was not a mistake. It was a scam — a deliberate, organized theft of the nation’s wealth disguised as patriotism.
Government inefficiency created the scam, and supported its continuation. Government must now intervene and make a difference in the lives of ordinary citizens by alleviating the cost of moving from one location to another. One option is to develop and optimize train transportation in the country.
In all of this, in spite of the stoppage, there is a yawning gap in the unfortunate saga. Those who designed, operated, and benefited from the scam need to be named tried, and jailed. Such thievery that has tied the nation down for decades cannot go unpunished. Also, the refineries must be made to work. The stolen trillions should be recovered, and ploughed into infrastructure development. The subsidy may be gone, but the scammers are still here. And that is a tragedy!
Dear readers, we really need your support to keep on serving you with authoritative, truthful, and juicy stories everyday. For your support, please reach out to the editor @gavelinternational66@gmail.com


